Italian cuisine is undeniably one of the most beloved and cherished cuisines worldwide. In upstate¬† New York it’s no surprise that Italian fare holds a special place in the hearts and palates of many. However, the recent closure of a top-rated Italian eatery in Sullivan County, NY, has left local residents and food enthusiasts feeling surprised and saddened.

The Hudson Valley is no stranger to the ebb and flow of businesses, where the restaurant scene can be as volatile as it is vibrant. Yet, it’s particularly disheartening when a highly acclaimed establishment abruptly closes its doors, leaving loyal patrons dissapointed. This was the harsh reality that fans of Crust Italian Eatery had to face as they discovered the shocking news on social media last month.

“Unfortunately, we have decided to permanently close our doors at Crust Italian Eatery a week early. We’d like to thank all of our customers for their 13 years of support. It’s been quite a ride.”


this is an image of the sign from the former Sullivan County restaurant "Crust Italian Eatery" by

Crust Italian Eatery, nestled in the quaint town of Rock Hill, New York, has been a cherished culinary gem in Sullivan County. It was a place where the tantalizing aromas of authentic Italian cuisine wafted through the air, beckoning locals and tourists alike. However, the sudden closure of this beloved establishment left a void in the hearts of its patrons that will be hard to fill.

The outpouring of reactions on the restaurant’s Facebook announcement was a testament to the profound impact Crust Italian Eatery had on its community. It was heartwarming to see that the memories shared by those who dined there were overwhelmingly positive. This sentiment echoed the restaurant’s remarkable reputation on Google Reviews, where it boasted an impressive 4.1-star rating based on over 200 reviews from satisfied customers.

What made Crust Italian Eatery stand out was not just the delicious dishes it served but the warmth and hospitality that greeted every guest who walked through its doors. From its delectable pasta dishes to its mouthwatering pizzas and delightful desserts, every meal was crafted with love and care. It was a place where friends and families gathered to celebrate special occasions, and where regulars became friends over a shared love of food.

The closure of Crust Italian Eatery serves as a poignant reminder of the challenges that small businesses face, especially in the ever-evolving culinary landscape. Despite the heartache of its closure, the legacy of this beloved Italian eatery will live on in the hearts of its patrons, the memories shared around its tables, and the flavors that tantalized taste buds.

As we bid farewell to Crust Italian Eatery, we are reminded of the importance of supporting local businesses and savoring the moments we spend in the company of good food and good friends. The culinary world may continue to evolve, but the memories created in cherished eateries like Crust Italian Eatery are timeless.

Farewell, Crust Italian Eatery. You will be deeply missed, but your impact on Sullivan County’s culinary landscape will never be forgotten.

Scroll to Top